You paid your premiums for years. You were hurt in a crash through no fault of your own. Now the company you’ve been paying is refusing to cover your medical bills.
If your no-fault benefits were denied in Michigan, that denial is often not the final word: state law gives injured drivers legal protections, including payment deadlines, penalty interest, and in some cases attorney fees, but the clock starts running the moment you get the denial. This is for Michigan car-accident victims whose no-fault/PIP benefits were denied after they were injured in a motor vehicle collision, regardless of fault. It explains why insurers deny claims, what Michigan deadlines and rules apply, what steps to take right away, and the answers to common questions. Many drivers pay for no-fault coverage expecting medical bills and wage loss to be covered after a crash, so knowing your rights quickly can make the difference between getting benefits restored and losing them.
Why Insurers Deny PIP Claims
The reasons tend to fall into a handful of categories:
- “Not related to the accident.” The insurer argues your injuries were pre-existing or came from something else entirely.
- Treatment “not reasonable or necessary.” Often based on independent medical exams the insurer orders; companies rely on them to assess your condition, symptoms, and ongoing care, even though not every evaluation is thorough or objective.
- A missed medical exam. Your policy likely requires you to attend exams the insurer schedules, often called an IME. Skipping one gives them an easy denial.
- Missing or late paperwork. Including bills submitted outside the timeframes discussed below.
- Fraud or misrepresentation. The insurer alleges errors on your application or claim forms and moves to rescind the policy.
- Priority disputes. The insurer says a different company should be paying, and you’re stuck in the middle while they argue.
- Benefits exhausted. More common since the 2019 reform let drivers choose lower PIP levels; for example, after a car accident, lower selected limits can leave coverage limited for later medical expenses or hospital bills.
What Michigan Law Requires of Your Insurer
Three provisions work in your favor.
Benefits are overdue after 30 days. Under MCL 500.3142, PIP benefits are overdue if not paid within 30 days after the insurer receives reasonable proof of the fact and amount of the loss. If only part of your claim is supported by proof, the insurer can’t sit on that part while disputing the rest.
Overdue payments earn 12% interest. That’s simple interest per year, and it’s automatic on overdue amounts. You don’t have to prove the insurer acted in bad faith to get it.
Attorney fees may come out of the insurer’s pocket. Under MCL 500.3148, if a court finds the insurer unreasonably refused to pay or unreasonably delayed payment, your attorney fees become a charge against the insurer, on top of the benefits you recover.
One warning on the 30-day rule. For medical benefits, if a bill isn’t submitted to the insurer within 90 days after the service is provided, the insurer gets an extra 60 days before the payment is considered overdue. So a provider who bills late can quietly hand the insurance company five months instead of one. It’s worth confirming your providers are billing promptly.
Watch the Deadlines
Two rules in MCL 500.3145 decide whether you can recover at all.
One-year notice. You generally must give your insurer written notice of your claim within one year of the accident.
The one-year-back rule. An injured person generally can’t recover benefits for losses incurred more than one year before filing a lawsuit, and filing too late can cut off benefits that otherwise would have been recoverable. For losses incurred on or after June 11, 2019, that period is paused from the time a specific claim is submitted until the insurer formally denies it.
That last phrase matters more than it looks. Courts have held that a vague or wavering explanation of benefits may not count as a formal denial. But once you receive a denial that is explicit and unmistakable, the pause ends and the clock is running again. Deadlines also apply to the appeal process, insurer responses, and other dispute steps, so act quickly after a denial. Don’t set the letter aside.
What to Do After a Denial
- Get the denial in writing, with the stated reason, and ask the insurer to explain the reason for the denial. If you were told no over the phone, ask for it in writing.
- File an internal appeal or written request for reconsideration with the insurance company. You can appeal a no-fault benefits denial, and starting that process promptly can make more sense than simply dealing with the cutoff alone.
- Keep treating. If your doctor says you need care, get the care. Gaps in treatment become the insurer’s main argument that you weren’t really hurt and can be used to question your ongoing coverage.
- Attend every independent medical exams the insurer schedules. The insurer uses these exams to assess whether treatment should continue, even when serious injuries and symptoms remain. Bring someone with you, and afterward write down how long the exam actually lasted and what was and wasn’t done.
- Ask your treating doctors or another healthcare provider to document that your treatment is related to the crash and medically necessary. Strong medical documentation and evidence tying your injuries and symptoms to the accident can support ongoing care. Their records carry more weight than the insurer’s hired examiner.
- Keep everything. Bills, explanations of benefits, denial letters, mileage logs, wage records, replacement services forms, and other claim documentation that may help you challenge or dispute the insurer’s decision.
- Confirm your providers are billing on time, for the reason described above.
- If the appeal fails, arbitration or a lawsuit may be necessary to pursue recovery and restore insurance benefits.
- Consider a complaint to DIFS. You can file a complaint about your auto insurer with the Department of Insurance and Financial Services, which oversees Michigan insurance practices and can require a written response from the company. Be realistic about what this accomplishes: DIFS can investigate whether the insurer is following the law, but it can’t act as your lawyer or order the company to pay you.
- Talk to a no-fault attorney or personal injury lawyers well before the deadlines close for help with the appeal process.
Common Questions
Can I afford a lawyer to fight my own insurance company? Most no-fault attorneys, including Ruby Injury Law, work on contingency. There’s no fee unless we recover. And where the insurer unreasonably refused to pay, the fees may be charged to the insurer. Using high-interest credit cards for treatment or bills can hurt your ability to negotiate while you are dealing with the denial.
The insurer paid some bills but not others. Is that a denial? It may be. Partial payments and vaguely worded explanation-of-benefits forms are exactly the situations courts have wrestled with. Have the paperwork reviewed rather than assuming. The paperwork should clearly explain whether coverage was denied in whole or in part and why.
They said my injury was pre-existing. Is that the end of it? No. Michigan law doesn’t require you to have been in perfect health before the crash. Aggravation of a pre-existing condition can be compensable.
What if I missed the IME? Reschedule immediately and get advice. A missed exam is a problem, not necessarily a fatal one. Many people do not realize how strictly this process is enforced until benefits are cut off.
The Bottom Line
Insurance companies count on people accepting a denial and walking away. Many do.
Michigan law gives you real leverage here: a payment deadline, penalty interest, and the possibility of making the insurer pay your attorney fees. But that leverage only exists if you act before the notice period and the one-year-back rule cut off what you can recover, because a denial can create financial stress and disrupt recovery.
No-fault claim denied? Call Ruby Injury Law at 248-539-7439 for a free review of your denial letter and denied no-fault insurance benefits. No fee unless we win.
About Ruby Injury Law — Ruby Injury Law is a Farmington Hills, Michigan personal injury firm founded by attorney Drew Ruby. The firm represents injured people across Michigan in auto negligence, food illness, and other injury claims. Call 248-539-7439 for a free consultation.
This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship.


